ºÚÁϳԹÏÍø

Low completion rates put OU on collision course with regulator

Provider with low graduation rates due to admissions policies struggling to meet Office for Students benchmark

January 4, 2023
Runners try and stretch out their fatigue to illustrate Low completion rates put OU on collision course with regulator
Source: Getty

The Open University¡¯s low completion rates could put it on a collision course with the English regulator, it is feared.

Figures obtained via a Freedom of Information request show that the specialist adult education provider ¨C the UK¡¯s largest academic institution with about 150,000 registered students ¨C only successfully graduates just over 20?per cent of its overall intake on average.

Of students who began modules in 2013-14, 21?per cent were marked as having completed their course, 7?per cent were still studying, 22?per cent had withdrawn and 51?per cent had ¡°lapsed¡±, the response showed, with similar numbers in 2012-13 and 2014-15.

It is understood that the completion rate is higher for undergraduate first-time degree students ¨C the university¡¯s largest population ¨C at 33?per cent over the past four years, and 37?per cent in the most recent year.

ºÚÁϳԹÏÍø

ADVERTISEMENT

These figures are still below the Office for Students¡¯ recently introduced threshold that it expects providers to meet for completion of part-time undergraduate degree courses, set at 40?per?cent.

The regulator has already lowered this threshold from 55?per cent and has signalled that it will take context into account when assessing whether to investigate providers performing below the benchmark. The part-time threshold for ¡°other undergraduate¡± courses remains at 55?per?cent.

ºÚÁϳԹÏÍø

ADVERTISEMENT

But it raises questions over how the controversial new condition ¨C which could see institutions stripped of their registration or subjected to other sanctions ¨C will apply to non-traditional institutions such as the OU, according to Ormond Simpson, a consultant and former director of the university¡¯s Centre for Educational Guidance and Student Support.

¡°I was, and still am, entirely committed to the OU and its ethos, and it saddens me that it may be under threat from the OfS,¡± he said.

Although Mr Simpson agreed that the OU had a responsibility to improve its graduation rate, which he said used to be a lot higher, its open entry policy ¨C which allows those with no prior qualifications to take courses ¨C and the fact that it can take students anywhere from six to 10 years to obtain a degree made the data difficult to interpret.

He also pointed out that new government guidance introduced in July states that all university course adverts should include comparable data on dropout rates, something that could again harm the OU if it appears without context.

ºÚÁϳԹÏÍø

ADVERTISEMENT

Dave Hall, university secretary for the OU, said comparisons between the institution and other universities were ¡°challenging¡± given the make-up of its student body, half of which comes from the lowest economic groups and 63 per cent of whom are first-generation students.

¡°Our unique model also allows, in most cases, students to pause and restart their study at any time, and this is not reflected in the student outcomes measurements,¡± he added.

Mr Hall said the OU ¡°plays a critical role in social mobility in the UK¡± and would continue to work with the OfS to ensure that this ¡°unique role in higher education continues to be recognised¡±.

Jean Arnold, director of quality at the Office for Students, said that outcomes measures were ¡°one part of the evidence we use to regulate higher education providers¡± and that judgements about whether a provider was compliant were made only ¡°after considering the context in which it is operating¡±.

ºÚÁϳԹÏÍø

ADVERTISEMENT

tom.williams@timeshighereducation.com

Register to continue

Why register?

  • Registration is free and only takes a moment
  • Once registered, you can read 3 articles a month
  • Sign up for our newsletter
Register
Please Login or Register to read this article.

Related articles

Reader's comments (3)

There are many reasons why the graduation rate for the OU is so low. Inevitably, having low or no entry criteria means that many people not suited to doing a degree may join up and only later realise that studying for a degree is not for them. On the other hand, many students may (I have no evidence for this) sign up because they want to complete a few modules. They may not be interested in getting a degree. They will show up as not completed, but it could be through active choice. The OU should not be compared to other institutions when it comes to these kinds of statistics.
I¡¯m sure there are several reasons why the OU¡¯s graduation rates are so low. But, if for example, students are signing up with insufficient idea of what they¡¯re taking on, then the OU needs to make much greater effort to ensure they get clearer and accurate initial advice. Anything less is unethical. That advice then needs to be followed by far greater support for such students. Again if graduation rates are low because many students are only committing to a few modules then the OU ought to have evidence to support that. I have some sympathy with the OfS position which is if you take on students you need to ensure that - provided they commit to their studies - they should have a fair chance of succeeding. I think that the OU's current graduation rates of little more than 20% suggest this is not happening. My concern is that the OU used to do considerably better. In the 80¡¯s and 90¡¯s graduation rates were around 50-60% despite the fact that new students were on the whole less well qualified on entry. Why have graduation rates declined so precipitously? Is it to do with the way the OU has moved into online learning? To not compare the OU to other universities is to deny that the Open University ¡°had to be a university with no concessions¡± as its founder Jenny Lee remarked, Ormond Simpson (author ¡®Supporting students for success in Online and Distance Education¡¯ ¨C Routledge). www.ormondsimpson.com
I wish my university had a lower completion rate.

Sponsored

ADVERTISEMENT